The “cruel abandonment” in medicine. The struggle against doctors’ inaction in cases of sudden death in the 18th century

Roberta  Fusco; Silvia Iorio; Rosagemma Ciliberti; Mario Picozzi

doi:10.23750/abm.v96i4.16430

The “cruel abandonment” in medicine. The struggle against doctors’ inaction in cases of sudden death in the 18th century

Authors

Roberta Fusco Department of Biotechnology and Life Science, University of Insubria, Varese
Silvia Iorio Department of Molecular Medicine, Unit of History of Medicine,Sapienza University of Rome
Rosagemma Ciliberti Department of Health Sciences, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy
Mario Picozzi Research Center in Clinical Ethics, Department of Biotechnology and Life Science, University of Insubria, Varese

Keywords:

sudden death, Apparent death, Public health reform

Abstract

In 1755, the medical field in Milan was characterized by a worrying reluctance of surgeons to intervene in cases of sudden death. This hesitancy, based on an alleged certainty of death founded on unreliable signs, caused considerable concern among local authorities and medical professionals. In an unpublished document, Doctor Guglielmo Parini, eminent member of the Illustrious Tribunal of Holiness of Milan, an institution responsible for supervising the health of citizens, expressed his dismay at the “cruel abandonment” of individuals considered dead without a thorough examination. His observations were based on numerous cases of presumed corpses, in which many individuals believed dead were actually alive, with their lives sacrificed due to misdiagnosis. Parini cites some of these cases of apparent death, taken from the dissertation of the famous anatomist Winslow, published eleven years earlier, in which the uncertainty of the signs of death was discussed.

Through the analysis of a text dated to 1775, we try to bring to light an aspect that characterized 18^thcentury forensic medicine.

References

1. Archivio di Stato di Milano. Sanità Parte Antica, busta 276, Morti subitanee. Ordine agli anziani per le diligenze da praticarsi in caso di morti improvvise.

2. Milanesi C. Mort apparente, mort imparfaite. Médecine et mentalités au 18° siècle. Paris: Payot; 1990.

3. Benigne-Winslow J. Quaestio medico-chirurgica: an mortis incertae signa minus incerta a chirurgicis, quam ab aliis experimentis. Paris: Quillau; 1740.

4. Zacchia P. Quaestiones medico-legales. Tomo I. Lyon: Jean Anisson & Jean Posuel; 1701.

5. Fusco R. Putridaria (strainer rooms) and draining practices of the bodies. In: Herring E, O’Donoghue E, editors. The archaeology of death. Proceedings of the Seventh Conference of Italian Archaeology held at the National University of Ireland, Galway, April 16–18, 2016. Oxford: Archaeopress; 2018. p. 532–9.

6. Bruhier J. The uncertainty of the signs of death, and the danger of precipitate interments and dissections, demonstrated with proper directions for preventing such accidents. London: M. Cooper; 1746.